South Bay Featured in San Francisco Business Times

Home Appraisals Lag Behind Sale Prices in Hot Real Estate Markets, Creating Gaps

Real estate appraisers must follow professional standards for evaluating home prices which, some real estate professionals say, don't always adjust to fast-changing markets. The process of determining the value of a single-family home in San Francisco is itself  undergoing a reassessment,  according to some real estate professionals in San Francisco and on the Peninsula.

During rapidly rising real estate markets, home appraisals often come in lower than a home's actual sale prices, creating challenges for buyers with mortgages. This happens because appraisers must look at comparable recent sales. But in hot markets like San Francisco, Atherton or Los Altos, prices can leap in just a few months.

"I've had it happen to me a couple of times with a listing for a buyer where we ratify price X and the appraiser comes back and says 'No.' So even though the house sold for a higher price, the appraiser appraised it at a lower price," Vanguard Properties President Frank Nolan told the Business Times. "The market's moving so fast that appraisers just can't keep up."

As old sales data can't justify the current inflated prices, real estate agents have reported seeing appraisals come in anywhere from $300,000 to $500,000 below purchase prices in some cases, a situation that puts buyers with mortgages at a disadvantage.

"Psychologically, it never feels good to have the home appraised quite a bit lower," Ken DeLeon, founder of DeLeon Realty in Silicon Valley, told the Business Times.

San Francisco Bay Area luxury home illustrating the difference between appraised market value and contract sale price.

Mind the Gap

Property taxes are linked to sale price, not appraisal price, so there's no tax upside for a buyer in this situation, DeLeon noted. On the flip side, a major benefit of being an all-cash buyer is avoiding the uncertainty of an appraiser coming in and appraising at a lower number because current sales can't be justified by sales three to four months ago.

Rapidly appreciating markets, often in coveted areas like Atherton and Los Altos, where DeLeon said prices are likely 8% to 10% higher than they were just four months ago, are particularly at risk of an appraisal gap.
"There's definitely issues of it not appraising. So for clients who are not the lucky ones — or not all-cash — I'll try to prep them that to be competitive they are going to have to pay more than an all-cash person if they are winning with a loan," he said, noting that he represented a few homes that appraised at about half a million lower than their sale price. With that aggresion, he noted, comes a "high likelihood that it won't appraise" for the amount buyers agree to pay.

Aftermath of the Crisis

Banks require appraisals to protect depositors and follow regulations put in place after the 2008-2009 financial crisis. Appraisers will generally come in within about a week after the home goes into contract. Smart buyers in hot markets prepare by having extra cash reserves beyond their loan amount, knowing that appraisals likely won't support the full purchase price they're paying.

When appraisals come in low, buyers can try to renegotiate the price with the seller or get a second opinion with another appraisal. However, in competitive markets like the AI-juiced San Francisco market, sellers often have backup offers and aren't motivated to lower their prices.
Larry Hebb, regional senior lender in the Bay Area for Northern Trust, said that one of the challenges associated with the financial crisis was that appraisals were were perhaps too fast and loose.

In today's world, banks and financial institutions typically use appraisal management companies, unless they set up an in-house appraisal unit.
"As a regulated financial institution, we need to have an appraisal," said Hebb. The appraiser will follow uniform standards, which typically mean using recent transactions as comparables, or comps.

Hebb said Northern Trust has its own supervisory loan-to-value requirements: "For example, on a $10 million loan, the maximum loan to value against the lower of purchase price or appraisal, is 65%. For us, the maximum loan amount can be curtailed if they don't make that. I will tell you, though, that most of the people who are buying homes in that bracket do not need to have a maximum loan."

Comp Crunch

Assessor discrepancies have been particular evident in the tenancy in common, or TIC, market, said Vanguard Properties agent Mark McHale. He related a story about a client who just went into contract on a two-unit TIC in San Francisco's Dogpatch neighborhood.

The bank wasn't concerned about the quality or the newness of the systems or the age of the roof, but there were no comps that they could pull from because it's not only such a limited facet of the market, TICs, but also there's so little inventory that's sold recently or nearby or within the last six months," he said. "And so we had to get a second appraisal on this property. The first one came in painfully low, like about $300,000 below purchase price, and the second guy, who was a more seasoned appraiser, went broader, more across the city rather than just staying in the Dogpatch, and did find ways to validate the price, so we got the deal to work. But it was a scramble."

If the data demonstrates a measurable increase, the appraiser can account for that change through supported market-condition adjustments, said Erik Ulrich, a certified appraiser and owner and operator of Velox Valuations South Bay. However, if the analysis does not support the contract price, the appraiser cannot simply increase the value to match it as the market evidence must guide the conclusion, he said.

"Appraisers value residential properties based on factual market data, not the emotion or momentum surrounding a hot market," Ulrich said. "When homes receive multiple offers and sell substantially above asking price, the contract price is important evidence, but it does not automatically establish market value."
Ulrich said an appraiser must analyze verified sales data, often looking back two to four years, to understand the broader market cycle. This includes quarterly and monthly trends to determine whether prices are truly increasing, decreasing or remaining stable. Listing and contract activity, days on market, sale-to-list-price ratios, concessions and the frequency of bidding above asking price also represent valuable data points for appraisers.

"In a rapidly changing market, an appraisal may occasionally come in below the contract price. That does not necessarily mean the appraisal is wrong or that the buyer overpaid," Ulrich said. "It may mean the contract reflects buyer competition, limited inventory or an emotional premium that has not yet been supported by enough closed sales.”

View Original Article San Francisco Biz Journal

Leave a Comment